A production subsidy that is granted to a producer of an import-competing good

 Options:

a. does not require governmental taxes to finance it b. yields the same deadweight welfare loss as an import tariff or import quota c. has only a consumption effect deadweight loss d. has only a protective effect deadweight loss

The Correct Answer Is:

d. has only a protective effect deadweight loss

Correct Answer Explanation: d. has only a protective effect deadweight loss

Let’s break down the concept of a production subsidy granted to a producer of an import-competing good and why option d is the correct answer, followed by explanations for why the other options are not accurate.

Option d states that a production subsidy granted to a producer of an import-competing good has only a protective effect deadweight loss.

This means that the subsidy aimed at supporting domestic production and competing against imports causes a deadweight loss primarily related to its protective nature, i.e., shielding domestic industries rather than taxing consumers or causing a general welfare loss.

When a production subsidy is provided to domestic producers, it artificially lowers their production costs, allowing them to compete more effectively against imported goods. This support aims to protect domestic industries and jobs.

However, this subsidy can lead to a deadweight loss that is primarily associated with its protective effect. Here’s why:

Protective Effect Deadweight Loss:

The subsidy distorts the market by incentivizing domestic production, even if it might not be the most efficient or cost-effective. This creates a deadweight loss as resources are allocated inefficiently due to the subsidy-driven production, leading to potential overproduction or misallocation of resources.

Now, let’s discuss why the other options are not accurate:

a. Does not require governmental taxes to finance it:

This statement is incorrect regarding subsidies. Subsidies are typically financed through governmental funds, which are derived from taxes, borrowing, or other revenue streams. When the government provides subsidies to domestic producers, it allocates resources from its budget to support these industries.

These funds ultimately come from taxpayers or from other sources within the government’s financial structure. Subsidies represent a direct intervention in the market, requiring financial backing from the government to sustain them.

b. Yields the same deadweight welfare loss as an import tariff or import quota:

This statement doesn’t accurately represent the unique mechanisms through which subsidies, tariffs, and quotas impact the market. While all three can lead to deadweight losses, their effects differ fundamentally.

Subsidies specifically aim to support domestic industries by providing financial assistance to producers, promoting local production and often shielding them from international competition.

The resulting deadweight loss primarily stems from the distortion of market forces due to the subsidy-driven production rather than direct market restrictions as with tariffs or quotas.

c. Has only a consumption effect deadweight loss:

This statement is inaccurate regarding the nature of production subsidies. Production subsidies primarily impact producers by influencing their output decisions and cost structures.

By reducing production costs for domestic producers, subsidies encourage increased production levels, potentially leading to overproduction or inefficient resource allocation. While subsidies can indirectly affect consumption patterns by influencing the availability and pricing of goods, their primary impact is on the production side of the market.

In essence, the distinctive characteristics of production subsidies lie in their role of supporting domestic producers, encouraging production levels, and safeguarding industries from foreign competition.

The deadweight loss associated with subsidies primarily arises from their protective effect, disrupting market equilibrium and leading to inefficiencies in resource allocation. This sets them apart from the mechanisms and impacts of tariffs, quotas, and purely consumption-driven deadweight losses.

Related Posts

• Research about differential reinforcement of sex-appropriate behavior suggests that
• In many cases, pioneers lose their market lead and initial market share to imitators who