Management Notes

Reference Notes for Management

Concerning import tariffs of the United States empirical studies tend to conclude that these tariffs are

Concerning import tariffs of the United States empirical studies tend to conclude that these tariffs are


a. progressive and thus bear down on the wealthy
b. regressive and thus bear down on the poor
c. proportional and thus bear down on all consumers in the same manner
d. deflationary and thus result in reductions in the price of imports

The Correct Answer Is:

b. regressive and thus bear down on the poor

Why is the correct answer (b) – regressive and bearing down on the poor?

Import tariffs in the United States are essentially taxes imposed on imported goods. Empirical studies suggest that these tariffs tend to impact lower-income households more significantly, making them regressive. Here’s why:

i. Spending Disproportionality:

Lower-income households spend a larger portion of their income on consumer goods, including everyday items, many of which could be imported.

Therefore, when tariffs are imposed on these goods, the increased cost directly affects a higher percentage of their income compared to wealthier individuals, for whom these expenses make up a smaller fraction.

ii. Essential Goods:

Tariffs often impact basic necessities such as clothing, food, and household items. These necessities form a more substantial part of the budget for lower-income families. When tariffs raise the prices of these goods, it creates a heavier financial burden on those with limited disposable income.

iii. Limited Alternatives:

Wealthier individuals might have the means to switch to more expensive domestic alternatives or absorb the increased costs without significantly altering their lifestyles. On the contrary, lower-income households may have fewer options or resources to offset these increased expenses.

Why are the other answers incorrect?

a. Progressive and bearing down on the wealthy:

Import tariffs are generally not progressive. The progressive taxation principle implies that those with higher incomes pay a higher proportion of their income in taxes.

However, import tariffs are not income-based taxes; they’re imposed on goods regardless of the purchaser’s income level. While tariffs on luxury items might affect the wealthier more, many essential goods subject to tariffs impact lower-income individuals significantly.

Thus, the impact isn’t inherently targeted at the wealthy but rather broadly affects various income groups.

c. Proportional and bearing down on all consumers in the same manner:

This option assumes that tariffs have a uniform effect on all consumers, regardless of their income. However, the reality is that tariffs impact different income groups disparately.

Lower-income households allocate a more substantial portion of their income to essential items, which are often subject to tariffs. This means that even if the tariff rate is the same for everyone, its impact isn’t felt equally across income brackets.

d. Deflationary and resulting in reductions in the price of imports:

Import tariffs generally don’t lead to reduced prices of imports. Instead, they often result in increased prices for imported goods. When tariffs are imposed, the cost of importing those goods rises, leading to higher prices for consumers.

While in some cases, suppliers might absorb part of the tariff to remain competitive, this doesn’t necessarily translate into reduced prices for consumers. The primary impact is usually an increase in prices or, at best, a moderated price increase due to market dynamics.

Understanding the nuances of import tariffs reveals that their effects aren’t uniform across income levels. Lower-income individuals tend to bear a disproportionate burden due to their higher reliance on imported goods for basic needs and their limited ability to absorb increased costs compared to wealthier individuals.

Therefore, while tariffs impact all consumers to some extent, they are particularly regressive, impacting lower-income households more severely.

Related Posts

Leave a Comment