How did nearly complete isolation as a child affect Danielle’s verbal abilities?

 Options:

a. She could not communicate at all. b. She never learned words, but she did learn signs. c. She could not understand much, but she could use gestures. d. She could understand and use basic language like “yes” and “no.”

The Correct Answer Is:

a. She could not communicate at all.

Correct Answer Explanation: a. She could not communicate at all.

Danielle’s nearly complete isolation as a child profoundly impacted her verbal abilities. The correct answer, a. She could not communicate at all, is accurate due to the severe deprivation of language exposure during her formative years.

When children lack consistent linguistic interaction, they face substantial challenges in developing speech and understanding language structures. This deprivation impedes their ability to grasp the fundamental aspects of communication.

Danielle’s situation reflects the reality of critical periods in language development. During childhood, the brain is highly adaptable and primed to acquire language. In cases of extreme isolation, where there’s no exposure to language, the brain doesn’t receive the necessary stimuli to develop linguistic capabilities.

Consequently, Danielle likely faced severe limitations in expressing herself verbally or comprehending language nuances.

Now, let’s delve into why the other options are incorrect:

b. She never learned words, but she did learn signs.

Learning signs or gestures typically stems from exposure to some form of communication, either spoken or visual. It’s a common misconception that individuals isolated from language might naturally resort to learning signs or gestures.

However, the development of sign language or gestures also requires exposure to linguistic concepts. Without any exposure to language, be it spoken, written, or signed, the foundation necessary to create and understand signs or gestures wouldn’t exist. Danielle’s complete isolation likely precluded her from acquiring any form of communicative gestures or signs.

c. She could not understand much, but she could use gestures.

Understanding and using gestures are closely tied to language comprehension. Gestures, along with verbal communication, are part of the broader spectrum of language development. They are typically acquired within the context of language exposure.

Without exposure to language, the ability to comprehend or produce gestures effectively is severely limited. Isolated individuals often lack the means to conceptualize or interpret gestures as a substitute for language due to the absence of a linguistic framework.

d. She could understand and use basic language like “yes” and “no.”

The capability to understand and use basic words like “yes” and “no” stems from exposure to language. These basic words rely on a foundation of linguistic understanding, which is absent in cases of severe isolation.

Understanding even these basic words requires exposure to language in context, where meanings are attached to specific sounds or symbols. In the absence of language exposure, Danielle would not have had the opportunity to grasp the meanings or uses of such basic linguistic elements.

In summary, Danielle’s complete isolation deprived her of any linguistic exposure necessary for the development of communication skills. Language acquisition is a complex process that requires consistent exposure to linguistic stimuli, whether spoken, written, or signed.

Without this exposure, the development of verbal abilities, understanding of gestures, or even the usage of basic words becomes an enormous challenge, as observed in cases of severe isolation during childhood.

Related Posts

• .What role do secondary groups play in society?
• According to social disorganization theory, crime is most likely to occur where?