Management Notes

Reference Notes for Management

Which of these is an example of a total institution?

Which of these is an example of a total institution?


a. Jail
b. High school
c. Political party
d. A gym

The Correct Answer Is:

  • a. Jail

A total institution is a concept introduced by sociologist Erving Goffman, referring to a type of institution where individuals live and work under a single authority’s control, and their activities and interactions are highly regulated and controlled. Total institutions have a significant impact on every aspect of an individual’s life, including their daily routines, behavior, and identity.

In this context, let’s explore why “jail” is an example of a total institution, and why the other options – high school, political party, and a gym – do not fit the criteria for total institutions.

a. Jail (The Correct Answer):

Jail is a classic example of a total institution. In a jail or correctional facility, individuals are subjected to strict rules and regulations that govern every aspect of their daily lives. Their movements, routines, and interactions are heavily controlled by the institution’s authorities. Some key aspects that make jail a total institution include:

1. Loss of Personal Freedom:

In jail, individuals are deprived of their personal freedom and autonomy. They are confined to a specific area and are unable to come and go as they please. This loss of freedom is a fundamental characteristic of total institutions.

2. Routine and Schedule:

Inmates in jail typically follow a strict daily schedule, which includes specific times for meals, recreation, work assignments, and other activities. This regimented routine is a hallmark of total institutions, where individual autonomy is replaced by a predetermined schedule.

3. Regulation of Behavior:

Jail authorities closely regulate inmate behavior, and any deviation from the established rules can result in disciplinary actions. This control over behavior is a defining feature of total institutions.

4. Isolation from the Outside World:

Inmates in jail are often physically isolated from the outside world. They may have limited contact with family and friends, and their interactions are often monitored or restricted. This isolation reinforces the concept of a total institution.

5. Institutional Identity:

In jail, inmates often adopt an institutional identity, with uniforms, inmate numbers, and specific roles within the facility. This transformation of personal identity into an institutional one is characteristic of total institutions.

b. High School:

A high school is not typically considered a total institution. While it does involve rules, regulations, and a structured environment, high school students maintain a level of personal freedom and autonomy that is not as severely restricted as in a total institution like jail.

High school students typically attend school during the day but return to their homes in the evenings, allowing for a degree of separation from the school environment. Moreover, high school students are not subject to the same level of control and isolation as inmates in a jail.

c. Political Party:

A political party is not a total institution. Political parties are voluntary organizations where individuals join based on their political beliefs and affiliations.

Members of political parties maintain their personal freedom and autonomy and are not subject to the same level of control, regulation, and isolation found in total institutions. While political parties have their rules and norms, they do not encompass every aspect of a member’s life to the extent that a total institution does.

d. A Gym:

A gym is not a total institution. Gyms are places where individuals voluntarily go for exercise and fitness. While gyms may have rules and regulations related to equipment usage, safety, and conduct, these rules are not as comprehensive or controlling as those in a total institution.

Gym-goers retain their personal freedom, are not isolated from the outside world, and do not undergo the transformation of personal identity into an institutional one, which are key characteristics of total institutions.

In summary, a total institution, as conceptualized by Erving Goffman, is a highly controlled and regulated environment where individuals experience a loss of personal freedom and autonomy, strict schedules, behavior regulation, isolation, and institutional identity.

Among the options provided, only “jail” fits this definition, as it encompasses all these elements. High school, a political party, and a gym do not exhibit the same level of control, regulation, and isolation that is characteristic of total institutions.

Related Posts

Leave a Comment